Minutes of
the Board of Directors Meeting
November 17, 2000
The Board of Directors of the
Lancaster County Solid Waste Management Authority met on Friday, November
17, 2000 at 7:30 A.M. at the Authority office, 1299 Harrisburg Pike, Lancaster,
PA.
ATTENDANCE
Board of Directors present were:
Chairman Frost, Ebel, Hammel, Kassees, Musser, Spangler, Varljen and Wood.
Absent was Clark. Staff present were: Warner, Forster, Garner, Lausch,
Norris, Olson and Dougherty. Also present were: Solicitor George T. Brubaker,
Hartman Underhill & Brubaker; Glenn Hoag and Tom Wilton, Ogden Martin
Systems of Lancaster; Ned Wehler and Steve Fulton, ARM Earth Resource
Engineers and Consultants, Hershey, PA; Ad Crable, Lancaster New Era,
a representative from WGAL TV-8, and citizens as listed on the sign in
sheet attached.
APPROVAL OF THE MINUTES
On motion by Kassees, second
by Hammel and unanimous vote, the Minutes of the September 15, 2000 meeting
were approved.
Chairman Frost reported that
there was an Executive Session held on Thursday, November 16, 2000 to
discuss personnel and real estate matters.
PURCHASE OF REAL ESTATE
OPTIONS
Chairman Frost called on Jim
Warner, who gave background information on the Authority's current
agreement with the County and the Authority's integrated waste management
system.
He explained that in order to
meet obligations to the County, it is necessary to begin planning for
additional landfill capacity because, currently, the Frey Farm Landfill
is projected to be full in the year 2018.
The Authority approached Manor
Township, who was in the process of rezoning, and asked if it would be
receptive to extending the current landfill area.
The Authority commissioned an
exhaustive study to investigate all of Lancaster County to see if there
was another site that would be conducive for a landfill. Based on the
conclusions of the study and the fact that the Manor Township land had
been rezoned, the Authority began negotiations with the primary owners.
Those negotiations took place over a period of approximately the last
six months, and an agreement was reached with the primary landowners within
the past two weeks.
In today's environment in
the solid waste field, it is virtually impossible to permit a Greenfield
(new) Landfill, especially in Pennsylvania. Any permits being granted
by the Department of Environmental Protection are for expansions. The
Authority is committed to expanding its operations in its current location.
The Authority has shown its
commitment to Manor Township, and has tried to be a good neighbor by insisting
that the landfill be run in the best way possible. Other investments include
donating 20 acres to the Township for a Community Park, and recently contributing
over $280,000 in site grading services to prepare for the development
of the Park. Also, the Authority has committed $75,000 for the restoration
of the Reiber House.
The Citizens Advisory Committee
met on November 16, 2000 to be briefed on the pending 2001 budget and
the pending real estate options related to land adjoining the Creswell
Landfill. The CAC requested this statement be entered into the record:
"In the best interest
of all residents of Lancaster County, the Citizens Advisory Committee
(CAC) to the Lancaster County Solid Waste Management Authority (LCSWMA)
hereby strongly endorses the efforts to take action concerning landfill
expansion which is consistent with sound long term planning necessary
in solid waste management. This is consistent with the Authority's
agreement with the County of Lancaster to provide an integrated solid
waste management system to the residents of Lancaster County through the
year 2030."
Warner recommended that the
Board approve Resolution No. 2000-4.
Board of Director Secretary
John Kassees read Resolution No. 2000-4 in its
entirety.
Chairman Frost opened the meeting
for public comment. (responses follow all comments)
Ron Harper - Mr. Harper expressed
his disappointment in the Authority Board and Executive Director for the
way they handled this issue.
Melvin Hess - (Attorney for
property owners within the rezoned area.) Mr. Hess requested that the
Resolution be tabled until the zoning issue is resolved and negotiations
are held with the other nine landowners.
Jim Huber - Mr. Huber commended
the Authority for their operations over the years. Mr. Huber noted his
disappointment with the Authority over not negotiating with all landowners
and he recommended the Resolution be tabled.
Donna Bare - Ms. Bare stated
she should be able to say what happens to her property.
Larry Kirchner - Mr. Kirchner
stated an industrial site should be used for a landfill.
John Haser - Mr. Haser asked
the Authority to discuss what other areas have been investigated for a
landfill site and requested the Board table Resolution No. 2000-4.
Ed Kladky - Mr. Kladky asked
1) if the Authority is concerned about the 1986 promise made not to expand
the landfill; 2) why did the Authority negotiate with just one landowner;
and 3) will it reveal the price in the agreement.
Mary Glazier - Ms. Glazier asked
1) if the decision to ask for rezoning was made at a public meeting or
in an executive session; 2) if the Resolution adopted in June 2000 was
done so at a public meeting 3) when was the decision made to talk to Manor
Township about rezoning; 4) if you remember the condition not to expand
the Landfill and 5) if you discussed at that time that condition with
the supervisors or employees of Manor Township.
Mike Bare - Mr. Bare asked how
the decision was made to negotiate only with the Barley family.
Fred Baum - Mr. Baum asked why
the Authority can't use the Narvon Mine or the Landfill north of Manheim
in the future.
John Haser - Mr. Haser asked
if Mr. Rob Barley was involved in negotiations while he was sitting on
the Planning Board.
Clabell Kladky - Ms. Kladky
stated that if the agreement signed by the Authority and Manor Township
can be negated, then no one's word is worth anything.
Larry Kirchner - Mr. Kirchner
asked how long the landfill expansion had been planned.
Jay Brenner - Mr. Brenner asked
what are the circumstances that the landfill would be filled by 2008.
There was no further public
comment.
Mr. Ebel moved to adopt Resolution
2000-4. Second by Hammel. A lengthy discussion by the Board of Directors
followed.
Chairman Frost called on Attorney
George Brubaker to explain the 1986 commitment not to expand the landfill.
Mr. Brubaker responded, noting that zoning is a governmental function
and is subject to change. The original condition imposed by the Zoning
Hearing Board in 1986 was part of the approval for the Frey Farm Landfill.
Mr. Warner responded to comments
as follows:
Regarding whether long term
planning should have started back in 1986: at the time we started landfilling
at the Frey Farm Landfill, we anticipated it would last 20 years. We are
trying to address long term landfill disposal needs.
Our decision to negotiate with
the Barleys was based on the fact that the Barleys et. al., own 284 acres
of land within the footprint of the proposed expansion. It made no sense
to talk to the other nine property owners until we had an agreement with
the owners of the 284 acres. If we would have come to an agreement with
the nine and not with the one who owned 284 acres, it would have been
a moot point.
The Authority is committed to
fair negotiations over due time. We are going to let residents dictate
timing. We understand that they feel they may be negatively impacted.
The property values are not damaged, and, for the record, the Authority
guarantees no property values would be diminished.
The Board of Directors passed
a resolution on June 16, 2000 which authorized the Executive Director,
in conjunction with the Solicitor, to pursue Landfill expansion.
The decision in August to proceed
with our long term plan and speak to them about zoning changes was a decision
of the Executive Director and Staff. It was management's job to know
that Manor Township was in the midst of township rezoning, it was part
of the course of normal business.
Regarding remembering the promise
made in 1986 at the zoning hearing board - this item was not discussed.
Rob Barley was one of the people
who participated. There was no discussion at all with the Planning Commission.
The Authority will work with
every property owner for a fair arrangement. We could have waited many
more years and just given five years notice.
Regarding the circumstances
that would shorten the Frey Farm Landfill by ten years: these are calculations
made in case the RRF becomes inoperable for whatever reason, and we would
have to accelerate the use of the landfill. If we did not have a Resource
Recovery Facility and Recycling, the Frey Farm Landfill would be full
today.
Regarding other sites for a
Landfill, Mr Ned Wehler, President of ARM Group, explained how the site
in Creswell is the best site to Lancaster County to accommodate a landfill.
Mr. Wood called for the question.
The Board unanimously adopted Resolution No. 2000-4.
Frost noted that Board Member Donna Clark was absent but she had indicated
her support of the Resolution.
The Board of Directors recessed
at 9:15 AM.
The Board reconvened at 9:30
A.M.
FINANCE DEPARTMENT
- Olson reported on the following:
-
LCSWMA Preliminary Results
Actual vs. Budget - All Programs for the Month and Ten Months Ended
October 31, 2000.
-
LCSWMA Accounts Receivable
Report and Past Due Detail Analysis as of October 31, 2000
-
Approval of Disbursements
- On motion by Musser, second by Varljen and unanimous vote, the Summary
of Disbursements for September and October 2000 in the total amount
of $7,545,828 were unanimously approved.
-
Audit Committee
- Chairman Frost appointed Hammel and Spangler to the Audit Committee
EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR'S
REPORT - Warner reported on the following:
-
Operating Results
- The operating surplus for the month was $329,709, after allocating
$850,000 to reserve funds. Strong trends in tipping fees and investment
earnings are responsible for the surplus. On the negative side, electric
revenue suffered severely for the month, coming in $296,000 under
budget due to an eight day unscheduled turbine outage.
-
Haulers Meeting
- The Annual Haulers meeting was held on November 9th.
All of the haulers that attended were very satisfied with the level
of service they are receiving at our facilities. Of course, they were
pleased to hear about the proposed rate reduction of $2.00 per ton
to the refuse tipping fee.
-
Debt Rating
- Standard & Poor's has upgraded the Authority's debt
rating from BBB to A-. This upgrade reflects the satisfaction with
our performance since the debt refunding in March 1998. We will be
contacting Moody's Investor Services to get them to upgrade their
coverage on us as well.
-
Resolution
No. 2000-3 - On motion by Wood, second by Kassees
and unanimous vote, Resolution No. 2000-3 was adopted. The Resolution
approved and adopted the 2001 Operating Budget, the 2001 Capital Projects
and Equipment Budget, and the 2001 Rules and Regulations.
ADMINISTRATIVE
SERVICES DEPARTMENT - Lausch reported on the following:
-
Waste Stream
Management - The Summary Tonnage Report - Actual Results
vs. Budget for the Month and Ten Months Ended October 31, 2000 was
reviewed. Total revenue tons received for processing and/or disposal
at Authority facilities in October were 56,826 tons. Year-to-date
total system tons are 549,025, or 14% ahead of budget.
-
Solid Residual
Waste - A meeting was held with Burnham Corporation
to discuss a new three year Agreement.
-
Liquid Residual
Waste - During October, 619,960 gallons of waste were
delivered to the Liquid Treatment Plant, the most gallons received
in a single month this year. Revenue for the waste was $31,189, or
$7,384 under budget. Revenue fell short because we had budgeted for
a clean out event which did not occur.
-
Recycling
- On November 18, the Authority will participate in an America Recycles
Day promotion at the Home Depot. The Lancaster store is the official
PA host for 2000 and may be visited by the Lt. Governor.
-
Insurance Renewals
- The Business Travel Accident Policy was renewed. The policy
provides $100,000 per occurrence and $1,500,000 aggregate coverage
to employees and Board members while traveling on Authority business.
-
Compensation/Benefits
- Work continues on updating the job descriptions for each position
in the Authority. Also, annual Employee Evaluations/Appraisals will
be performed in November.
-
The contract for our Employee
Assistance Program has been renewed with Life Management Associates.
The cost this year for core services is $3,513.75.
OPERATIONS DEPARTMENT
- Garner reported on the following:
-
Landfill -
Placement of select waste over the floor of Cell 4D has been completed.
With Cell 4D now "covered", we no longer need to operate
two separate filling areas.
-
Safety -
There were no reportable accidents or injuries in October. All three
facilities earned a free lunch by working a full month with no accidents
or injuries.
-
Purchase of Replacement
Roll-Off Containers - On motion by Hammel, second by Kassees
and unanimous vote, the Board awarded the contract for the purchase
of six roll-off containers to Eagle Equipment Corporation for the
bid price of $20,550.
-
Purchase of Replacement
Pickup Truck - On motion by Varljen, second by Ebel
and unanimous vote, the Board awarded the contract for the purchase
of a new pickup truck to Hondru Ford, Inc. for the bid price of $24,356.
RRF CONTRACT ADMINISTRATION
DEPARTMENT - Forster reported
on the following:
-
Site Operations
- Electric revenues for October were $879,125, or $296,875 below budget,
due to an unscheduled turbine outage. The turbine was down nearly
eight days to repair a steam inlet valve, resulting in a loss of approximately
$297,000 in electric revenues to the Authority.
-
A total of 29,929 tons of
waste was delivered to the facility in October, or 3% less than last
month.
-
Regulatory Activities
- Randy Weiss visited the site on October 19 for a routine inspection.
His report did not contain any operational violations.
-
Other Activities
- Craig Davis of R.W. Beck, our RRF consultant, was
on site from October 10 - 11 to inspect the boilers and perform other
work related to the annual facility audit.
-
A preliminary partial report
has been received on the fall stack testing showing results below
permit level. Final results will be available in 30 days.
TECHNICAL SERVICES DEPARTMENT
- Norris reported on the following:
-
In response to a DEP Bureau
of Air Quality request, we completed and submitted a Minor Permit
Modification application relative to the RRF Title V Permit. The "Minor
Mod" will revise an operating condition for the furnace dry lime
injection system.
-
Approval of Proposal
for Phase 2 Capping Project - On motion by Kassees,
second by Hammel and unanimous vote, the Board approved the Agreement
with ARM Group for consulting engineering services for the Phase 2
Capping Project in an amount not to exceed $185,000.
OTHER BUSINESS
A letter recommending the reappointment
of John K. Musser for an additional five years has been forwarded to the
Lancaster County Commissioners.
The Board of Directors unanimously
approved the Salary Plan for 2001.
The Nominating Committee presented
the following slate of officers for 2001:
William K. Ebel, Chairman John
S. Kassees, Secretary
John Musser, Vice Chairman
Barbara B. Hammel, Treasurer
Hammel moved to close the nominations.
Second by Varljen. A unanimous ballot was cast.
PUBLIC COMMENT
Tom Wilton of OMSL stated that
Ogden Energy has changed its corporate name to Covanta Energy effective
January 1, 2001.
ADJOURNMENT
On Motion by Kassees, second
by Ebel and unanimous vote, the meeting adjourned at 10:10 A.M.
APPROVED BY THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS
OF THE LANCASTER COUNTY SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT AUTHORITY THIS 15TH
DAY OF DECEMBER, 2000.
John S. Kassees, Secretary
|